Former Progressive Muslim leader (although self admittedly not a Muslim by belief) Hussein Ibish is here promoted by Jeffrey Goldberg for his attacks on the idea of the one-state solution which is gaining strength among a strand of Palestinian activists here in America.
Ibish, who is currently described as “Senior Fellow at the American Task Force on Palestine” (referred by As’ad Abu Khalil as the “Dahlan Lobby” or “Dahlan Embassy” in Washington). Ibish seems to be frustrated that his pro two-state arguments are not being engaged by the one-state proponents, including Ali Abunimah. Ibish used to be at least professionally close with Abunimah, coauthoring several items, but claims that Abunimah views have shifted radically in recent years. He know accuses him of being an extremist and an Islamist sympathizer (all of this discussion is taking place essentially among secularist thinkers, although some Muslims are undoubtedly supporters of Abunimah and Abu Khalil, etc. in their critique at least). Let me be clear that Abunimah does engage with all range of arguments and critiques of his one-state proposal in his book and in the media, but apparently has chosen not to engage specifically with the work of Mr. Ibish.
Now, Mr. Ibish is interviewed at some length by Jeffrey Goldberg (a figure whom I, shall we say, do not admire) about how the one state solution is fantasy. I actually have had some conversations with a Modern Orthodox Rabbi here in Chicago with whom I have done several interfaith programs, who is planning to move next year to Israel, who is also a supporter of a one state solution.
Let me say that although I certainly oppose occupation and support the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination, I personally find it hard to get excited about or invested in supporting a Abu Mazen/Dahlan bantustan state as the outcome of the long Palestinian/Muslim struggle in the holy land. I understand the difficulties of a one state solution but it is more inspiring to me than the illusory peace process. Again, at the end of the day I am really an observer. Although I am emotionally invested due to the sacredness of Jerusalem, my love for my Muslim brothers and sisters in Palestine, and my concern for all humans everywhere including Israelis and Jews, I realize that it is not up to me to decide what the Palestinian people do, let alone can I determine what Israel will do.
