New York Times: ‘Extremism spreads across Indonesian penal code.’
Most of Indonesia still lives up to its reputation for a moderate, easygoing brand of Islam, and Islamist parties suffered heavy losses in this year’s national elections. But how Aceh went from basic Islamic law to endorsing stoning in a few short years shows how a small, radical minority has successfully pushed its agenda, locally and nationally, by cowing political and religious moderates.
Though extreme, Aceh [which recently passed the death penalty by stoning for adulterers] is not an isolated case. In recent years, as part of a decentralization of power away from the capital, Jakarta, at least 50 local governments have used their new authority to pass Shariah-based regulations regarding conduct and dress, though none have gone as far as Aceh to deal with criminal matters.
Rural Acehians support stoning:
People in Aceh’s rural areas were said to be Shariah’s staunchest supporters, though even most people interviewed here in the provincial capital said they backed the stoning of adulterers.
“If people are caught, they should be given a warning the first time,” said Fati Ibrahim, 43, a mother of four who was buying dustpans at a large store here. “But if they’re caught a second or third time, they should be stoned.
“Otherwise, they’ll give Aceh a bad image. They’ll embarrass us outside Aceh, that we’re not practicing Islam as it should be.”
What would the neighbors think?

thabet 11:00 pm on October 27, 2009 Permalink |
Would the New York Times ever cast the support in the US for the illegal invasion of Iraq in such terms? Or perhaps not, given it cheered on an invasion which may have killed hundreds of thousands through direct and indirect actions by the ‘coalition’.
bingregory 11:21 pm on October 27, 2009 Permalink |
Aceh has had a sustained armed resistance against the State since Independence. Moving to a federal system with some regional state-level autonomy rather than a single centralized state is the only way to solve that problem. Stoning of adulterers is far preferable to a return to civil war, just as it was in Afghanistan. After a generation or two of peace and genuine home rule I’m sure they’ll mellow out. On the other hand, considering the oil and gas Aceh is sitting on, chances are not good that they will be left alone that long.