Silence and invisibility for the sake of Neda:
Her image is no longer that of a woman in death but rather a sign of Iran’s oppressive regime. Neda’s agency is denied, and in her passing we cannot afford her privacy but continually reproduce an image of her death which to me resembles a Warhol pop art print. Neva Mwiti writes a really strong analysis of Stolen and the controversy surrounding it. She asks whether or not “film producers, brand gurus and marketers from the West will realise and respect that the third world is not fodder for their notoriety, but actually made up real people, with real feelings and real rights over their own destinies and identities.” I think her comments can be applied to the majority (if not all) representations of women like Faitim and Neda. When will these women be given the respect they deserve?
Neda’s agency is denied by limiting the scope of her possible desires to one – “privacy,” a state of silence and invisibility.
Next we should examine what we know about Neda’s thoughts on the political behavior she was engaged in and was killed for. From Wikipedia:
* Her music teacher, Hamid Panahi, who was accompanying Agha-Soltan during the protest, told the media: “She couldn’t stand the injustice of it… All she wanted was the proper vote of the people to be counted. She wanted to show with her presence that, ‘I’m here, I also voted, and my vote wasn’t counted’. It was a very peaceful act of protest, without any violence.”
* Caspian Makan (Agha-Soltan’s fiancé) told BBC: “Neda had said that even if she lost her life and got a bullet in her heart, she would carry on”.
She was engaged in an act of expression when she died, in a public place for all to know and see. She stepped out of anything that was part of her normal regular life to be public and to be heard. To then say that the highest respect we can pay her is “privacy” is to steal the agency – the meaning that she ascribed to the last few minutes of her life.
Speaking of non-Western perspectives, this commenter at Racialicious was fairly bursting with respect for them:
If I am not mistaken…it is the Iranian dissidents who are pimping Neda Soltani’s blood-ridden face all over the Internet. It is a certain political group of Iranians who are dying for attention from the Western corporate media.
Paraphrased thusly: “I just hate non-Westerners who won’t get with my program and let me colonize them…”
